Windows Azure DevTableGen.exe issue with x86 assemblies on 64-bit Windows

I ran into an issue with a Windows Azure project created from scratch in Visual Studio 2010 Beta 1 with the May CTP of the Windows Azure Tools.Azure_Logo

When trying to create tables in the local development storage, I got the error “Invalid image format”. This issue occurred both from VS (using the Create Test Storage Tables option) and when running DevTableGen.exe manually from a command prompt. It didn’t occur when doing the same in VS2008.

DevTableGen.exe is a tool from the Windows Azure SDK. This tools loads an assembly, reflects over it and then tries to create tables in the local development storage.

After some head scratching I figured out the cause: in Dev10 the default target platform for executables was changed from AnyCPU to x86. In Beta 1 a bug snuck in, so that x86 is also the default for class libraries (DLLs). This will be changed back to AnyCPU in Beta 2. This blog post from Rick Byers has a lot of detail on why the default has changed.

DevTableGen.exe is an AnyCPU executable, so it will run as a 64-bit process on an 64-bit version of Windows. As such it cannot load assemblies marked as 32-bit only when run on 64-bit Windows. The solution was to change the assembly to AnyCPU.

This issue would have been prevented if DevTableGen.exe was marked as 32-bit only. That way it would always run in a 32-bit process and could load x86 and AnyCPU assemblies. According to the blog post linked to above, it is now considered best practice to explicitly mark an executable as x86 or x64. For most applications x86 is the best option.

I’ve suggested this change to the product team.

Update: I've been informed that DevTableGen.exe will not be changed. This is because this issue is temporary and will go away when VS2010 Beta 2 is released. Also the web role and worker role processes in Windows Azure are 64-bit, so trying to load x86 assemblies will fail anyway. So if you use Beta 1 make sure you explicitly change the platform for any assemblies you create for the cloud to AnyCPU.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *